Files
nick-doc/Issues/ISSUE-003-route-shadowing-post-api-disputes-purchaserequestid-resolve-.md
Siavash Sameni 7a616744f4 docs: complete code-reality alignment for remaining docs + reconcile issue set
Remaining docs updated to match code (the docs that the first pass had not covered):
- Flows: Chat, Referral, Rating, Registration, Google OAuth, Negotiation, Payout,
  Trezor Safekeeping — corrected endpoints, socket events, status enums, auth gaps
- API Reference: User API, Trezor API — admin route prefix/verb/status corrections,
  added undocumented endpoints (ton-proof challenge, profile email verify,
  GET /trezor/account, POST /trezor/verify-operation)
- Data Models: Chat, Notification, Payment, PointTransaction, User — corrected
  enums (PaymentProvider, escrowState, PointTransaction.type, User.status),
  90-day notification TTL, soft-delete semantics, wallet fields

Trezor "zero frontend" finding (audit C31/C32) corrected as STALE:
- Verified current code HAS a full frontend Trezor implementation (admin/trezor
  page, TrezorSettingsView, trezorConnector via @trezor/connect-web,
  TrezorSignDialog, actions/trezor.ts building the {message,signature} object)
- Fixed Trezor Safekeeping Flow doc (removed false "no frontend" warnings)
- Reclassified ISSUE-012 as invalid/superseded with explanation

Issue set reconciled to a single canonical numbering (ISSUE-001..054):
- Adopted the comprehensive 51-issue set (long-slug, fully indexed)
- Removed 35 superseded short-slug duplicates from the first pass
- Removed a duplicate ISSUE-046 file
- Added 3 issues the 51-set lacked: ISSUE-052 (completed-not-counted-in-stats),
  ISSUE-053 (axios 401-only interceptor), ISSUE-054 (rate limiter counts all attempts)
- Regenerated Issues Index: 53 open (14 critical, 39 major) + 1 invalid

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-05-29 15:15:02 +04:00

42 lines
1.7 KiB
Markdown

---
issue: 003
title: "Route shadowing: POST /api/disputes/:purchaseRequestId/resolve matches dashboard router first and executes wrong handler"
severity: critical
domain: Dispute
labels: [bug, backend, critical, escrow]
status: open
created: 2026-05-29
source: Doc vs Code Audit 2026-05-29
---
# 🔴 Route shadowing: POST /api/disputes/:purchaseRequestId/resolve matches dashboard router first and executes wrong handler
**Severity:** critical
**Domain:** Dispute
**Labels:** bug, backend, critical, escrow
## Description
Both the dashboard disputeRoutes and the releaseHold disputeRoutes are mounted at /api/disputes in app.ts. The dashboard router is mounted first (line 521). A POST /api/disputes/{purchaseRequestId}/resolve with a valid purchaseRequestId will match the dashboard router's POST /:id/resolve (Dispute CRUD resolve) before reaching the releaseHold router's escrow-unblocking resolve. The escrow hold is never cleared.
## Current Behavior
The dashboard router intercepts the request and executes Dispute model CRUD resolve only. Escrow hold is not cleared. Outcome is non-deterministic depending on whether the ID matches a Dispute _id.
## Expected Behavior
POST /api/disputes/:purchaseRequestId/resolve should reach the releaseHold handler and clear the escrow hold. Route registration order must be corrected or paths made unambiguous.
## Reproduction Steps
POST /api/disputes/{validPurchaseRequestId}/resolve with admin token — observe that escrow hold is NOT released, only the Dispute document is updated.
## Affected Files
- `backend/src/app.ts`
- `backend/src/routes/disputeRoutes.ts`
## References
- [Doc vs Code Audit Report](../09%20-%20Audits/Doc%20vs%20Code%20Audit%20Report%20-%202026-05-29.md)